Economic Substance Doctrine Tax Felonies (6/1/11)

I write today to provide viewers access to Jasper Cummings' article, Jasper L. Cummings, Jr., Economic Substance Doctrine Felonies, 131 Tax Notes 977 (May 30, 2011) and 2011 TNT 104-10 (5/31/11). (This article is provided with the permission of Tax Analysts.)  Mr. Cummings writes on the use of the economic substance doctrine in criminal tax cases. Most particularly, he writes about Mr. R. J. Ruble who was convicted in the first round of Son-of-Boss criminal prosecutions. In that case, Ruble, a tax lawyer, was convicted along with John Larson and Bob Pfaff who provided financial services in the conceptualization and implementation of the shelters. Two prominent subsequent shelter prosecutions have also used the economic substance doctrine in the charges to the jury.

First, let me disclose that I represented one of the dismissed defendants in the sprawling prosecution that ended up in the conviction of Messrs. Ruble, Larson and Pfaff. Once my client was dismissed along with 12 others before trial, I no longer had an immediate interest in the case but I did observe the progress of the proceedings through conviction and appeal and now pending petition for certiorari in the Supreme Court. I was particularly interested in whether and how the economic substance doctrine would be presented to the jury.
Read more »