Foreign Bank Account Records and the Required Records Exception to the Act of Production Doctrine

For those exposed on foreign accounts (i.e., no FBARs and no income tax reporting), the Government is brandishing a weapon that some taxpayers may not anticipate -- end-runs around the Fifth Amendment that would otherwise apply to avoid incriminating oneself. The end-runs are the "required records" exception to the Fifth Amendment and possibly the "foregone conclusion" exception to a Fifth Amendment act of production claim. I have previously blogged on the foregone conclusion exception here and focus here on the required records exception.

Just for background, there is now no Fifth Amendment privilege for the contents of documents (not even diaries which are, after all, not made under compulsion), but there is a Fifth Amendment privilege under the "act of production" doctrine relating to the testimonial aspects of compulsory production of documents (i.e., identifying documents, acknowledging their existence, etc.). So, the Fifth Amendment privilege is alive and well for compulsory document production in many cases. Hence, the Government needs end-runs such as the required records exception and the foregone conclusion exception.

Read more »